Concert review in The Christian Science
Monitor, October 26, 1929
high-resolution image news3.tif
(118 kb LZW compression)
"A
New Piano-Action"
By Winthrop P. Tryon
New York
Piano-Action -- who knows what that
means? When a tuner took the mechanism of keys and hammers out of an old
square piano of mine last summer and bade me shut the door so that the
wind, which was blowing into the house freshly from the west, might not
do it harm, I got an idea of what a piano-action is; something very delicate
when removed from its proper place and ever so slightly exposed to irregular
treatment, and yet something capable of enduring wear and weather almost
illimitable when set in the case as intended to be by the builder.
For all I know, the action of pianos has changed
a good deal since the square, which I happen to treasure, was put forth
from the factory, though, according to such casual observations as I have
made, it has remained in general idea about the same. Now I lately looked
under the lid of a grand piano and saw an arrangement of levers that appeared
unusual, a great number of sticks formerly required being dispensed with.
The instrument in question stood
on the platform of Town Hall and was being taken in hand by the movers,
to be carted home to the warehouse. To me, it was an extraordinary object,
while to them it was just a load for the truck; so I had little time to
satisfy my curiosity. Such, however, as I did have sufficed, since a piano,
after all, is its tone, which you do not see; and of this one I knew the
tone — a quality just enough different from anything I am used to, to make
me wonder if a fresh timbre in the year 1929 has been brought into existence.
Harold Bauer's piano I'm speaking of, a
concert grand lately out of the shop, carrying an action developed, information
goes, in the experimental department of the American Piano Company, by
C.N. Hickman, the physicist of the organization. It was played upon by
Mr. Bauer at the Festival of Chamber Music at the Library of Congress,
Washington, and it was played upon by him again here at the Town Hall on
the evening of October 19.
Pianist and Carpenter
Truly I am not going to try to make anyone
believe that the new action, being a mere product of the bench anyway,
had anything to do with the effect of Mr. Bauer's performance. Indeed,
I am sure that the whole matter is a case of coincidence. A musician's
artistry has taken on a certain interesting change, and an engineer's knack
at invention has evolved a mechanical device (hoping "device" is a dignified
enough term) at the same moment.
Not precisely the same, either; for Mr.
Bauer impressed me a year ago, when playing upon an instrument of the regular
type, to be passing from one period as interpreter to another. He seemed
to be getting well out of a state, which I thought he had for some time
been in, of a want of confidence in himself, as though he had completed
his communication and was leaving the next thing to be said by others.
Austerity and positiveness, united with charm and suavity -- there's the
four-in-hand of traits that's Bauer; and nobody from a piano company's
research laboratory will show him how to drive the team, either.
Bauer, then, was ahead of the carpenter.
Nevertheless, both at Washington and in New York, I particularly took to
the sound of the piano with the new action, equalized from top to bottom,
like the scale of a good singer; a kind of sound that carries, even when
very lightly produced, and one that does not offend the ear when brought
out with full power of the hand.
Am I unwittingly praising the man who travels
with Mr. Bauer, keeping the wires at the right tension and the hammers
at the desired velvetness? Very well; let me commend him as having achieved
a "voicing" that was most remarkably correct and appropriate for two of
Mr. Bauer's pieces in particular; the F major Ballade of Chopin and the
'Reflets dans L'eau' of Debussy."
Equalization
Equalization -- to take a little thought
of that as a tendency in instrumental expression today; upper notes a little
less piercing and lower notes a little less gruff than formerly. It can
be plainly observed, I think, in the orchestra, as a conductor like Arturo
Toscanini adjusts ...
[At this point the photocopy becomes difficult
to read and transcribe; there is no further mention of the piano or Bauer.] |