I wish to comment on what seems to be a popular topic for discussion.
That topic concerns whether or not music on band organs is able to
compete with popular music of today.  I must say it is not possible or
fair to compare today's "super-star" vocalists to music heard on band
organs.  Having said that, I wish to give credit to two arrangers who
have been able to revitalize band organ music to the point where the
people who ride on carousels are not only whistling to the tunes but also
clapping their hands when they should be holding on to the brass pole.
I am referring to Rich Olsen of San Diego and Bob Stuhmer of New York.

I've been a carousel operator for over 15 years, and I must say that
in most cases people show only a passing interest in our Wurlitzer 146b
organ.  However, as soon as I put on Rich Olsen's "Big Band Swing"
roll, I hear comments from the adults about the highly improvisational
style of the music they hear.  The tunes are recognizable and catchy.

Another prolific arranger who has been able to capture the riding
public's interest (both young and old) is Bob Stuhmer.  Our carousel has
both of his "Children's" rolls as well as his very popular "Halloween"
roll.  We have a lot of children up to the age of 12 celebrating their
birthday at our carousel.  Invariably we get requests to play the
"Children's rolls as the tunes on these rolls are familiar to everyone.

Finally, people who ride carousels will show a positive interest in the
band organ only if it is in good playing condition.  The music played
doesn't have to be "modern."  People still enjoy listening to a stirring
Sousa march so long as the organ plays well and is in tune.  There are
no recordings that can ever take the place of a Military Band Organ.

George Karpel
Burnaby, British Columbia